Thursday, July 12, 2007

Vet accused of punching dog indicted

The full article is below, but basically the dog wasn't cooperating with the vet, and he decided to punch the dog in the head 3 times, dislodging the dog's eye. In another incident, he was supposed to vaccinate the dog, but instead shot the vacine in the air and charged the owner 80 bucks.

Don't people become vets because they love animals?? How could you hit a dog so much that his eye pops out and call yourself a vet? That's like a human patient being beaten up by his doctor because he was a difficult patient.

http://www.azcentral.com/community/westvalley/articles/0710abrk-vetindicted0710-ON.html

Becky Bartkowski and Michael Kiefer
The Arizona Republic
Jul. 10, 2007 12:52 PM

A Sun City West veterinarian accused of animal abuse and theft has been indicted.

A grand jury issued Dr. Joshua Winston's criminal indictment on June 29. Winston was charged with one count of animal abuse, a felony, and one count of misdemeanor theft.

"These allegations are very disturbing, especially against a veterinarian," said Maricopa County Attorney Andrew Thomas. "People who entrust their pets to veterinarians have every right to expect good medical care, not vicious abuse."

Winston was arrested June 11 after being accused of punching Bella, a five-pound Chihuahua five times in the head. Winston allegedly struck the Chihuahua's head three to five times and dislodged the dog's eye on June 4.

Winston was unable to repair the eye damage and sewed it shut, Thomas said. Bella needed corrective surgery after the incident.

Two veterinary technicians witnessed the abuse and said that the uncooperative dog angered Winston. One of the witnesses reported that Winston struck Bella three times, Thomas said.

Winston had a history with the Chihuahua, named Bella, since he performed a cesarean section for Bella's birth last year.

The theft charges come from a separate incident in earlier this year, when Winston was to vaccinate a Neapolitan Mastiff and instead of vaccinating the dog, Winston shot the vaccination into the air and charged the dog's owner, Jeff Orth, $80.

"We will aggressively prosecute this case," Thomas said at the conference.

Jean Steenbock, a customer of Winston's, said, "I'm very disappointed."

"I had hoped that if he could tell his side of the story things would have turned out differently," Steenbock said.

Steenbock has a 14-year-old Bichon she needs euthanized and said she was planning to have Winston perform the procedure.

“As long as Joshua Winston is a vet practicing out here, I will continue to use him,” Steenbock said.

Winston is the owner of Sun City West Animal Hospital and is the sole doctor at the hospital.

The Arizona State Veterinary Examining Board and the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office investigated the case. The County Attorney's Office filed a complaint with the Arizona State Veterinary Examining Board, and Thomas thanked Sheriff Joe Arpaio and his officials for their continued fight against animal abuse.

10 comments:

Albert Belle said...

You mean you can't punch your dog? Punching things always works for me when I cet mad. Huh? Who knew?

Anonymous said...

For those that don't get the reference, Albert Belle was a baseball player who had some run-ins with the law.

jan said...

This is a horrible case. I hope he is punished very severely for a long time.

Anonymous said...

I would like to give all of you a follow up on this. We went to Dr. Winston’s hearing before the AZ Executive State Board — they dismissed ALL charges against Dr. Winston without violation. Within the testemonies of all parties involved - there were many things uncovered. One — Linda was tormenting the dog with a rabies pole prior to Dr. Winston taking Bella out of the cage prior to surgery. He took Bella out of the cage without incident - though she was scared - she was fine. It was when Linda appeared in front of her that she went nuts. Sr. Winston - holding the dog properly - so she would not get injured - was moving with her. Because of the pressure building up behind the eye - the eye prolapsed. THROUGH FORESNSIC EVIDENCE - it was varified that she WAS NOT HARMED like these girls are saying. They stated that he hit Bella 5 to 6 times on the side of the face. Folks - I have the police reports - along with - not one - but 3 vets who stated their was NO BLUNT FORCE TRAUMA TO BELLA - if Dr. Winston would have hit this dog like these girls are saying - SHE WOULD BE DEAD! All three vets - 2 by the way are board certified opthomologists - even stated this was unfortunate - but not even a slightest muscle tear / bruise was found behind the orbital - and the muscle attached. there is NO DAMAGE to Bella - and she has gained 100% eye sight and full recovery.

Anonymous said...

I would like to give all of you a follow up on this. We went to Dr. Winston’s hearing before the AZ Executive State Board — they dismissed ALL charges against Dr. Winston without violation. Within the testemonies of all parties involved - there were many things uncovered. One — Linda was tormenting the dog with a rabies pole prior to Dr. Winston taking Bella out of the cage prior to surgery. He took Bella out of the cage without incident - though she was scared - she was fine. It was when Linda appeared in front of her that she went nuts. Sr. Winston - holding the dog properly - so she would not get injured - was moving with her. Because of the pressure building up behind the eye - the eye prolapsed. THROUGH FORESNSIC EVIDENCE - it was varified that she WAS NOT HARMED like these girls are saying. They stated that he hit Bella 5 to 6 times on the side of the face. Folks - I have the police reports - along with - not one - but 3 vets who stated their was NO BLUNT FORCE TRAUMA TO BELLA - if Dr. Winston would have hit this dog like these girls are saying - SHE WOULD BE DEAD! All three vets - 2 by the way are board certified opthomologists - even stated this was unfortunate - but not even a slightest muscle tear / bruise was found behind the orbital - and the muscle attached. there is NO DAMAGE to Bella - and she has gained 100% eye sight and full recovery.

Mobile said...

SynergyVets is dedicated to providing quality recruitment services for locum and permanent Vets and Vet Nurses throughout the UK.

Regards.
http://www.synergyvets.com

Anonymous said...

Get fast cash advances from these trusted lenders. It is very easy to apply for guaranteed cash advance.

pandoraing said...

pandora jewelry For the most part, ankle bracelets are cheap pandora beads casual accessories: they are best pandora beads sale worn on an ordinary day out having fun. Multicolored pandora beads sale anklets woven from fibers or threads look pandora glass beads great with casual sandals or flip-flops. However, ankle pandora bracelet bracelets made of fine-spun gold and pandora bangle silver make a beautiful tandem with fashion shoes, and Pandora necklace look great for formal events. There are many different kinds of leather bands available in cheap pandora charms stores now. For women, colored leather or pandora earrings suede bracelets and watch bands are popular.

negocios rentables said...

I want have to know more and more, on your blog just interesting and useful information.

Anonymous said...

bear grylls messer
Here is my weblog ... bear grylls messer